Horseshoe Beach Real Estate: Gulf-Access Living at the End of the Road

Horseshoe Beach sits on a point of land jutting into the Gulf at the end of County Road 351, about 19 miles southwest of Cross City. It's a small town built almost entirely around fishing and boating, with canals running between the streets and sunsets over open water at the end of Main Street.

Horseshoe Beach market snapshot (October 2026)

About 35 properties are for sale, from about $65,000 to $850,000, with an average asking price near $250,000. Much of the inventory is land, much of it on the water, along with a smaller number of homes.

Living in Horseshoe Beach

  • Groceries and most errands mean a drive to Cross City, about 19 miles away.
  • Douglas-Butler Memorial Park, named for the town's founders, is the local waterfront park.
  • Shired Island, about six miles away, has a quiet beach and a county campground.
  • Inshore flats fishing, offshore trips, scalloping and kayaking all start from your own dock.

A little history

The land was once owned by lumber companies. In 1935, C.C. Douglas and Burton Butler bought it and offered each resident the lot they lived on for $10. Residents incorporated the Town of Horseshoe Beach in 1963.

Know before you buy

Horseshoe Beach sat in the path of three hurricanes in 13 months in 2023 and 2024, and many homes were damaged or lost. Several listings are cleared lots or as-is homes, which can be good value for buyers ready to build elevated. Check flood zone, permits and insurance costs early.

Want a canal lot with Gulf access?

Sign up for free Horseshoe Beach alerts and we'll send new listings the day they hit. Contact us or call (352) 498-5151.

Sources: Florida Nature Coast guide; Horseshoe Beach, Florida; Florida Backroads Travel.

For Sale in Horseshoe Beach

258 W 7th Ave, Horseshoe Beach
$849,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 799272 MLS
What's Special, OCEAN FRONT VIEW, CONVENIENT ONE LEVEL LIVING, NEW SEAWALL, TANKLESS WATER HEATER, NEW ROOF, GUTTERS, DOWNSPOUTS, SINGLE CELL INSULATION WITH METAL SOFFIT, NEW 2ND FLOOR DECK WITH LARGE STORAGE ROOM! One of Horseshoe Beach's Finest. A Luxurious 2/2 fully furnished ocean front home overlooking the Gulf of America with spectacular sunset views. The many special features were built strong and stylish with comfort in mind. The open and spacious floorplan has a gorgeous gourmet kitchen with Corian counter tops, wooden cabinets, and beautiful tile flooring. The dining room has seating for 8. A Florida room off the kitchen has seating for 4, hardwood flooring, six large double paned windows with remote controlled shades. A split-level sunken family room has cedar walls, tile flooring, sky light, and electric fireplace. The spacious master bedroom features king sized bed, a skylight and a master bath with His/Hers jetted shower, tile floors, spacious cherry wood cabinets, and vanity. A second bedroom has a queen sized bed, tiled floors, and an adjacent full sized bath. An office/laundry room has a desk and filing cabinets, and front load washer and dryer. The enclosed screened porch has beautiful cedar walls, vinyl plank flooring and French doors. Zoned A/C w/twin units, aluminum freight elevator, large carport, boat slip, and lift with dock. For your enjoyment, the nature coast area of Florida provides inshore/offshore fishing, scalloping, shrimping, crabbing, birding, kayaking, etc. This home is perfect for short term rentals, second home or as your primary residence. Come experience a laid-back lifestyle! Motivated Seller!

258 W 7th Ave, Horseshoe Beach

502 Main St Unit 207, Horseshoe Beach
$275,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 797590 MLS
Wake up to sweeping Gulf views and salty sea breezes from your private balcony in this sought-after condo at Horseshoe Cove. Unobstructed views of the Gulf and designed for easy coastal living, this inviting retreat sits in a quiet waterfront community where boating, fishing, and sunset golf-cart rides are part of everyday life. Just a short walk from the Gulf, the condo offers quick access to a deep-water boat ramp with direct channel access—perfect for guests eager to get on the water without delay. Inside, the open and functional layout includes two bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and a flexible bonus room currently set up as a third sleeping area (with under-bed storage) and office space with accordion windows, making it ideal for maximizing rental potential. This unit also comes FULLY FURNISHED including dishes and linens. Some artwork does not convey. The kitchen features well-maintained laminate countertops, generous cabinet storage, with a stackable w/d in the adjacent utility room, while the primary suite enjoys water views and primary bath with tub, walk-in shower and separate water closet. Convenience is key, with assigned parking directly below the unit and easy access to the elevator and stairs. Guests and owners alike will appreciate the community amenities, which include a waterfront pool, boat dock (repairs underway), boat wash station, and fish cleaning area. Whether you're looking for a personal coastal getaway or a strong short-term rental opportunity, this Horseshoe Cove condo delivers the perfect blend of relaxation, recreation, and income potential. This community just completed $2.5 million in major improvements, including a new roof, new hardiboard siding, new exterior paint, new impact resistant doors and windows, helping reduce maintenance and increase long-term value. Add to that their fully funded reserve account, and new owners can feel confident in this purchase. Also listed in Stellar MLS GC536909

502 Main St Unit 207, Horseshoe Beach

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!